• December 19, 2014
  • Welcome!
    Welcome | (Logout)
  • RSS
  • Contact
  • Archives
  • About

Alligator

Preachy Keen: ACLU is right to defend church’s freedom of speech

Print
Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Tuesday, November 24, 2009 12:00 am

When the Dove World Outreach Center, a local church, chose its name, the story of Noah must have come to mind.

After the great flood, Noah released a dove, which returned carrying an olive branch, revealing that somewhere there was land. The dove has since symbolized peace.

But don’t let this church fool you — its message is not even close to one of peace. On the contrary, it was probably another part of the flood story that attracted this church to its namesake: the drowning death of the wicked, corrupt masses.

Yes, this church hate-group doesn’t stick to run-of-the-mill Internet hate speeches. You know, the tried and tested (yet somehow consistently vile) “Abortion is murder, homosexuality is sin” stuff. That’s certainly part of the church’s platform, but they take their mission to “preach and challenge” to an entirely different level.

The church’s Web site plainly states that followers must “take a stand against Islam,” which is actively “leading people to hell.” They encourage all Christians to take this message directly to the people (and the sinners).

Which is exactly what some church members did at a Gainesville high school football game in early October. Along with their children, these weekend crusaders wore matching shirts that read “Islam is of the devil.” School officials and police, understandably perturbed by this visible hate speech, demanded that the parents and students leave school property.

Unfortunately, this is a somewhat familiar story. But something is missing.

Enter the ACLU.

Not those whiners, you might be saying to yourself. The same thought crossed some minds here at the Alligator.

Now, we hate hate-speech, probably more than these phony “Christians” hate people with different beliefs.

But we were (somewhat reluctantly) pleased to hear that the ACLU filed a federal lawsuit on Monday on behalf of the church. The suit claims that the school intruded on these crusaders’ freedom of speech when it removed them from the football game. The suit also seeks to reverse the Alachua County School District’s decision to bring disciplinary action against students who wear similar shirts to school.

How can the Alligator defend this hate-mongering, especially when the church seeks to send its message out on the chests of children?

We can, and we must, because without absolute freedom of speech, we might not be able to call the Dove World Outreach Center a bunch of crazy assholes.

Were it not for the freedom of the press and other freedoms we enjoy as Americans, we might not have the opportunity to share views about this church or other contentious issues.

The First Amendment is designed to protect the thoughts and opinions of everyone, and by necessity, it must include those fringe elements of society that we all wish would just shut up.

While we doubt the church will be successful in its efforts to spread its message through the schools, as the Supreme Court has routinely ruled that students give up many rights when entering school doors, we defend their right to do so. Further, we applaud the ACLU for taking on the difficult job of representing them.

The Alligator supports civil dialog, controversial discourse, and downright belligerent argument (we especially like arguments), even when we painfully disagree with others’ viewpoints.

So don’t censor the hate-groups. Just hate them back — publicly.

Welcome to the discussion.

7 comments:

  • bEEarCUB posted at 10:53 am on Fri, Apr 23, 2010.

    bEEarCUB Posts: 23

    Dove is pretty flatly vile, not to mention quite confused about others and the origins of their beliefs, but I do support their legal right to free speech ... as long as it stays just speech.

     
  • pegLa posted at 10:30 am on Sun, Nov 29, 2009.

    pegLa Posts: 2

    There is a God and Our America was founded on that belief. If you do not believe in Jesus you need to move from America. I am sick and tired of you people trying to take God out of our country. We have woke up to what you are trying to do and we will fight you!! God is real and Jesus is here to save you!

     
  • pegLa posted at 10:29 am on Sun, Nov 29, 2009.

    pegLa Posts: 2

    There is a God and Our America was founded on that belief. If you do not believe in Jesus you need to move from America. I am sick and tired of you people trying to take God out of our country. We have woke up to what you are trying to do and we will fight you!! God is real and Jesus is here to save you!

     
  • votermouth posted at 4:32 pm on Tue, Nov 24, 2009.

    votermouth Posts: 91

    There are separate regulations for public schools for a reason. If someone wants to wear a shirt with a hateful, ignorant message in public, the First Amendment protects them. But in school, other people's children shouldn't have to look at the prejudiced viewpoints of some kids' parents. When I have children, I'd love to send them to school in shirts that say, "There is no God." But I'm not going to do that because it's not right to use children to further your own agenda. Children should be able to learn in peace and leave the political and religious wars to adults.

     
  • dfroggley posted at 3:28 pm on Tue, Nov 24, 2009.

    dfroggley Posts: 2

    What you all fail to realize is that civil liberties don't really exist in schools. It is school policy that must be adhered to, and turning the school into a political forum is disruptive to the learning environment.

     
  • freedom posted at 10:35 am on Tue, Nov 24, 2009.

    freedom Posts: 2

    I support Dove World Outreach Center. We are slowly losing our freedoms in America. Its time that we wake up to what is happening. Its time that somebody had the guts to actually take a stand and act rather than talk politics. “Abortion is murder, homosexuality is sin”. This is the truth.

     
  • FranIngram posted at 9:28 am on Tue, Nov 24, 2009.

    FranIngram Posts: 2

    The Dove is a symbol of the Holy Spirit, the spirit of Jesus Christ, God himself. Jesus is called Mighty Warrior as well as Prince of Peace. Jesus came to bring peace between God and man, but also to destroy the work of the Devil.

    Yes, we like the story of Noah, not because the wicked were destroyed. That was tragic but necessary in God's eyes. Sin does lead to death, unless there is repentance through Christ. Noah was a man of faith (Hebrews 11) and through him his family was saved, with plenty of preaching and warning to those who later refused that salvation.

    And we don't hate anyone, never said we hate anyone. 'Hate speech' is just a convenient label for anything people are afraid of - it is an excuse to avoid facing he truth. We hate the Devil and all his work. Why would Jesus have died on the Cross for the sins of the world if he really hated them?