Say goodbye to Paynes Prairie's roaming herds.

Most of the American bison, Spanish cracker horses and shrub cattle that roam Paynes Prairie Preserve State Park will be removed by Dec. 31, according to an internal e-mail sent out June 9 by David Jowers, manager of Paynes Prairie.

Jowers has been planning to cut back the bison herd since 2008.

In a memo sent to Donald Forgione, director of Florida Park Service, on Sept. 23, 2008, Jowers said the bison herd should be decreased because the herd has grown too large over the years and could be a security hazard.

"Paynes Prairie Preserve's boundary has much denser human and domestic animal populations," Jowers said in the memo, "increasing the likelihood of escape onto surrounding roads and properties, creating risk of injuries."

The bison herd will be cut down from about 40 bison to about eight female bison, which means the smaller herd won't be able to reproduce. The horse herd will be cut back similarly. The e-mail did not say how many of the cattle would be removed from the roughly 40 that graze at Hickory Ranch, the park's cattle ranch.

The bison and horses would be given to people who submitted requests for the animals by June 30. According to the internal e-mail, the preservation would provide "all labor, equipment and material to remove 45 American bison alive (including all males)." People with approved requests would be able to catch and keep the park's bison and horses. The e-mail did not say if the preserve would sell or give away the animals.

The bison and horses currently roam on more than 21,000 acres of land owned by the preserve.

The remaining bison, horses and cattle will be confined to a smaller area south of the park's visitor center observation tower so guests will have a better view of the animals, according to the internal e-mail.

"When you look outside and you look over the fence, they aren't there," Forgione said.

He said that another reason the park is removing most of the livestock is to stop inbreeding.

Forgione said the Florida Park Service believes this is the best course of action after consulting with UF geneticists and the National Bison Association, a non-profit organization that matches bison sellers to meat buyers.

Jim Matheson, assistant director of the National Bison Association, said he did not know if the Florida Park Service was selling any bison through the association. The Florida Park Service was not registered to sell the animals at the association's annual bison auction.

In the 2008 memo to Forgione, Jowers mentioned the possibility of letting the bison herd die out.

"By eliminating the reproduction of the herd we can more easily choose to maintain, expand or let the herd go extinct," the memo stated.

Editor's note on 9/21/10:  The Dec.  31 date referenced is not a deadline for removal but was proposed language for a draft request to vendors.  At this time, there is no official plan in place for removing bison from the park.

Amy Graham, interim press secretary for the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, wrote in an e-mail, “Our goal is to have bison, Spanish cracker horses and cattle remain at the park at all times.”


(4) comments

Le Rouge

"Forgione said the Florida Park Service believes this is the best course of action after consulting with UF geneticists and the National Bison Association, a non-profit organization that matches bison sellers to meat buyers."

Boy sounds like they have the animals best interests in mind!


This is terrible, and i really don't get it. 45 bison don't have enough room on 21,000 acres??? So what if they knock over a fence.

no one can see them, yet having 45 of them risks injuring people: which is it?

And the prairie is NOT a petting zoo; reducing the healthy herd to 8 females stuck standing around the visitor center sucks. Why not add a sign at the visitor's center: " we sold all the male bison to meat factories and there are no bison actually on the prairie. We just keep these here to give the impression wild animals roam free! Enjoy your view"

Can the reporter also figure out whether the public has a say in this??? Are they not accountable to the public, the majority of which I imagine would prefer that the horses and wildlife remain free on the prairie instead of shipped off to make glue and ground meet or confined at the entrance to create a fake spectacle.


This is "the rape of the natural world." I hope they dont follow through with this. I have been within 20 yards of a herd of around 20 bison with calves at Paynes Prarie and there were no problems at at all.


All you liberal folks in Gainesville should be use to the government doing what they think is best for you. I go to Paynes Prarie all the time to view the horses, cattle and the bison. When they are gone I will just support the parks nearer to Ocala rather than driving all the way to Micanopy to spend my money. Resource managers always think they have to restore the ecosystem to the way it was 10,000 years ago. They are usually egg head government types that don't realize this is 2011 and the world has changed alot since then or they have ego problems and need that "power" to justify their jobs. Speak up Gainesville! This is your park - if you want the bison and horses there do something about it. Write your State Representives and Governor Scott.

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language. Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated. Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything. Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person. Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts. Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.