Skip to Content, Navigation, or Footer.
We inform. You decide.
Friday, December 01, 2023

Early voting for the Gainesville City Commission special run-off election ends

Cynthia Chestnut and Matt Howland face off for City Commission At-large Seat B

<p>Judi Jackson, a 62-year-old election volunteer (left), sits outside Alachua County Supervisor of Elections Office Jan. 22 with her fellow volunteer, checking early voting ballots. The special run-off election for City Commission At-large Seat B
 will be held Jan. 25. <br/></p>

Judi Jackson, a 62-year-old election volunteer (left), sits outside Alachua County Supervisor of Elections Office Jan. 22 with her fellow volunteer, checking early voting ballots. The special run-off election for City Commission At-large Seat B will be held Jan. 25.

Despite the subfreezing temperatures and blustery weather, over a thousand voters made their way to Gainesville’s two early voting sites throughout the weekend.

The Gainesville City Commission Special Election began Friday and ended Sunday, with the official election date being Jan. 25.

For voters casting their vote by mail past the early voting period, the mail-in drop box will be available Jan. 24 and Jan. 25 at the Alachua Supervisor of Elections Office at 515 N. Main St. Suite 100.

The two candidates on the ballot for City Commission At-large Seat B are former state representative Cynthia Moore Chestnut and former U.S. Army Emergency Response Chief of Communications Matt Howland.

Alachua County Supervisor of Elections Kim A. Barton noticed an increase in mail-in ballots. There were 1,353 in-person voters reported and 7,427 mail-in ballots returned in total – the collection of mail-in ballots began Jan. 3.

“The numbers are increasing voting by mail. It’s so easy, so accessible. Also, they don't have to pay for return postage,” Barton said. 

During the second day of early voting, retired city staffer Judi Jackson sat outside the Alachua County Supervisor of Elections Office in 40-degree weather, a broken heater perched next to her, as she made sure those returning their ballots had all the correct information filled out. Jackson will be in charge of verifying IDs on the actual election date. 

“I work every election doing different things,” 62-year-old Jackson said. “We just make sure that they sign them on the back and that they're sealed.”

The two election candidates originally campaigned for the position alongside Scherwin Henry, Patrick Ingle and Gabe Kaimowitz in November to fill the vacancy left by Gail Johnson’s resignation. However, a runoff election became necessary when no candidate received more than 50% of the vote.

“It was something that was unexpected for us,” Barton said. “We thought that the election in March, the city of Gainesville election in March of 2021, was our last standalone election for the city of Gainesville.”

The first special election had more than 11,000 voters and ended with Chestnut at a 560 lead over Howland.

After the election, Howland and Chestnut jumped into action by knocking on doors and learning more about the people in their community.

Enjoy what you're reading? Get content from The Alligator delivered to your inbox

“Lots of people think they know what the community wants and they know what the voters want but you don't actually know unless you go out there and you speak with them,” Howland said. 

Howland believes his policy positions are in alignment with the city’s needs and have remained consistent.

“I've maintained the same policy positions since Sept. 7, when I filed. I have not changed my position. I have not pandered, I have not flipped on a single position,” he said.

Howland’s total reported monetary contributions sum up to $21,055. 

He attributes the $17,682.48 spent by his campaign on total expenditures and distributions to high wages for his campaign team.

“We’re creating good paying jobs; $20 an hour for these young adults,” he said. 

Chestnut reported $19,786 in monetary contributions with $14,633.34 spent in total expenditures and distributions. She said the money was allocated towards print media, television, and radio.

Chestnut believes there is a need for more communication between the citizens of Gainesville and its city commission.

“I want them to know that they will have an advocate for citizen engagement, an advocate for neighborhoods and an advocate for lower utility rates,” she said. 

Gainesville resident and voter Byron Flagg believes both candidates possess the potential to fill the seat and execute their jobs well. The 49-year-old loves greeting all the volunteers at the site when he goes in to vote. 

“I love my city. I love my community. If you love your community and your city, and you want to have a say in how it's run and how it grows, you have to vote,” Flagg said. 

Chestnut and Howland will both be watching the polls Tuesday night in anticipation of the election results. 

Contact Melanie at or follow her on Twitter at @MelanieBombino_

Support your local paper
Donate Today
The Independent Florida Alligator has been independent of the university since 1971, your donation today could help #SaveStudentNewsrooms. Please consider giving today.

Melanie Pena

Melanie Peña is a second-year business and journalism major. When she's not designing a graphic or writing an article, she's probably making jewelry or exploring coffee shops in Gainesville.

Powered by SNworks Solutions by The State News
All Content © 2023 The Independent Florida Alligator and Campus Communications, Inc.